Amy Jean’s first recording was made when she was two. Her dad captured an a cappella rendition of “Somewhere Over the Rainbow” on a cassette recorder, preserving a performance she remembers as breathless, barely intelligible and full of heart.
Years later, the singer-songwriter based between Toronto and Haliburton has a similarly generous way of thinking about the recordings she releases. Asked how she knows when a performance is ready, even if it isn’t technically perfect, she offers a three-word answer.
“Perfect is boring.”
That conviction runs through Living Imperfection, her debut five-song EP. For Amy, releasing these songs meant accepting them as a record of where she is now, with room left to grow.
Finding the courage to write
Music had always been part of Amy’s life, but songwriting came later. Her love of other people’s work initially made it difficult to imagine creating her own. The songs she had grown up with set a standard that felt out of reach.
“As a music lover, there is a self-imposed barrier of thought that I couldn’t possibly write a song as impactful as the songs I grew up listening to.”
Encouragement helped change that perspective. A friend named Steve invited her into a songwriting peer group, initially just to listen. Being in that room gradually made writing feel like something she wanted to try herself.
Among the artists who expanded her sense of what a song could do was Ani DiFranco. Amy points to the force and candour of her lyrics, and her willingness to address subjects Amy hadn’t previously heard in songs.
“She blew up my thinking of what a song could be, with powerful, unapologetic lyrics that stop a person in their tracks.”
That attraction to vulnerability also draws her to Damien Rice, Amigo the Devil, Phosphorescent and The Civil Wars. Rainbow Kitten Surprise is another favourite. Across those influences, Amy responds to the feeling that a person is allowing something real to come through.
Letting a song find its shape

Her own writing moves between guitar and piano without a fixed rule about where a song should begin. Sometimes the choice is practical: a chord is easier to play on one instrument. A recent song took shape on piano before she decided she preferred its sound on guitar.
“Between the Notes” felt different. For Amy, that song needed to exist on piano, although friends have since been encouraging her to try a rock version. She sees the possibility of another arrangement as evidence of a song’s strength.
“It is a testament to a song, I think, if it can be re-imagined in different ways.”
That openness extends to performing material before it reaches its final form. After one listener explained an interpretation Amy hadn’t intended, she discovered that a word in the lyric had two equally valid definitions. She changed it. Hearing the song through someone else’s ears had helped her say more precisely what she meant.
The thread through Living Imperfection
When it came to choosing the EP’s songs, Amy had a clear sense of what held them together.
“Every song on the EP has an element of feeling seen or seeing someone else. That is what made it feel like a collection for me.”
A sixth song was being recorded, but she left it off because it didn’t share the same feel. Although releasing singles may appeal to her in future, she values the experience of a collection with a common thread.
The recording process also changed her understanding of “Divided in Union Station.” Working with Nicholas Russell, Amy used the piano to suggest an arriving train and a commuter’s footsteps through the station. Recreating that environment revealed something she hadn’t initially heard in the song.
“I initially thought of the song as an observation but in trying to recreate the feeling of being in a station, quickly realized that it was a warning.”
The approaching train became a way of understanding the social divide she was writing about. The arrangement had helped clarify the song’s meaning.
Amy also welcomes the small sounds that make a recording feel like a person playing an instrument. The guitar-string noises someone else might choose to record again are, to her, part of its humanity.
“These songs will never be perfect because the definition of perfect is so subjective.”
Her interest in those details has grown as AI-generated music has become part of the landscape. What she increasingly craves, she says, is “the humanity of imperfection.” Releasing her first EP without expecting it to be flawless has been liberating.
Making music with other people offers another kind of freedom. Amy’s collaboration with Kate Hall gives her the chance to do something she particularly loves: sing harmony. She admires Kate’s melodic phrasing and appreciates the support they can offer each other. The pair will open for Martin Kerr in Haliburton on June 5, 2027.
“Harmonizing may be my favourite thing to do in the whole world.”
With Living Imperfection released, she is writing more songs, exploring different sounds and looking for opportunities to step outside familiar territory. Collaboration is part of that next chapter: a chance to hear another perspective and see where it might lead.
On February 18, 2027, Amy will join Makinna Givens and Makenzy Williamson for NFTC Presents at Toronto’s Junction Underground. Her aim for the evening is straightforward.
“I would like to deliver an honest performance and hope that something in the songs can speak to anyone listening.”
It’s a fitting ambition for a songwriter whose first recorded performance was already full of heart, long before she had the breath to finish it comfortably.
See Amy live
NFTC Presents
Thursday, February 18, 2027
Junction Underground · Toronto